Matchy Matchy Make my game

Remember When Game: Turn Old Photos Into Table Stories

An older man and a young woman laughing over a game of Matchy Matchy at a cafe table

A remember when game is a storytelling game played with photos: you draw a picture, tell the story behind it, and everyone else adds what they remember. It needs no board and no score sheet, just a stack of photos and a table of people who were there for at least some of them.

Matchy Matchy turns your own photos into a memory card game, and the deck makes a ready-made draw pile for this one. Below are the rules written for a Matchy deck, how the game plays with grown-up friends and across generations, which photos to pick, and a few house rules.

How do you play the remember when game?

Low angle across a grid of game cards with two matching family photo cards turned up in front

You play the remember when game by taking turns drawing a photo card, telling its story, and letting the table fill in the rest. Here are the rules for a Matchy deck, where every photo appears twice.

  • Players. Two to eight. More than eight works if people play in teams.
  • Deck size. 24 cards, twelve photos twice, suits most tables. Use 12 cards for a quick round before dinner and 48 cards for a long night.
  • Setup. Shuffle the cards face down and stack them in the middle as a draw pile. Leave room beside it for a row of face up cards, the story row.
  • Your turn. Draw the top card and turn it so everyone can see. Tell the story behind it: where you were, who is in it, what happened just before or after.
  • Remember when. Going around the table, each player can add one thing they remember, starting with the words "remember when." Then the card goes into the story row.
  • The twin. When you draw a photo whose twin already sits in the story row, add one new detail nobody has said yet. Do it and you keep both cards. Draw a blank and the pair goes back in the box.
  • Winning. When the pile runs out, the player holding the most pairs wins and picks the first photo next time.

Points are optional. If your table stops counting halfway through, that is fine. The stories are the real prize.

How does it play with a group of grown-up friends?

Four adults around a living room table in the middle of a card game, one reaching for a card

With a group of grown-up friends, the remember when game turns fast and loud, because everyone was there and everyone remembers it differently. The first apartment, the road trip where the car died, the wedding where it poured all afternoon. Each photo starts a friendly argument about what really happened.

House rule: the fib

The teller slips one made-up detail into the story. Anyone who catches it on the first guess claims the photo: the card stays in the story row, and when its twin is drawn the pair goes to the catcher instead of the drawer. Friends who have known each other for years get very good at this, very quickly.

House rule: the veto

The person in the photo gets one veto per game. They can say "pass" and the card goes back in the box, with its twin once it turns up, story untold. Use it wisely. Saving the veto for the haircut photo is a classic move.

Mixed friend groups play well in teams. Pair someone from the early days with someone who joined later, and let the newcomer ask questions instead of adding memories.

How does it play across generations?

An older man points at a game card on a cafe table while a young woman grins across from him

Across generations, the remember when game becomes a way for grandparents to tell the stories nobody thought to ask about. The oldest players hold the longest memories, so give them room. Nobody needs a timer when Grandpa is explaining how he bought his first car.

Younger players get a different job. Instead of adding a memory, each one asks a question about the photo. Who took this picture? Where is that house now? Why is everyone wearing hats? A grandchild who was born long after the photo still gets a full turn, and the questions often pull out the best stories.

The game fits holiday tables well. Play it between dinner and dessert at Thanksgiving, or leave the draw pile next to the pie at Christmas. A deck that lives in the drawer at Grandma's house comes out every visit.

House rule: the next chapter

When the twin of a photo comes up, the youngest player at the table chooses who tells what happened next.

Which photos work for a remember when deck?

Eight family photo cards scattered face up on a warm walnut table

The photos that work for a remember when deck each hold one clear moment with a story behind it. Faces should be easy to spot, and the people at the table should know at least some of them.

For a family deck

  • The old house. The kitchen, the porch, the yard before the fence went up.
  • A wedding. Any wedding in the family, the older the better.
  • The road trip. The camper, the motel pool, the flat tire.
  • The holiday table. A dinner from years back, with people who are no longer at it.
  • The pets. The dog everyone still talks about.

For a friends deck

  • The first apartment. Bonus points for the terrible couch.
  • The concert or the game. Blurry is fine if the faces show.
  • The trip that went wrong. These always tell best.

Old prints work too. Photograph them with your phone near a window, then ask each relative to send one favorite of their own.

Why use a Matchy Matchy deck for it?

A photo card of a blonde woman turned face up among matching card backs on a table

A Matchy Matchy deck works for the remember when game because every photo comes twice and every card back looks the same, so the twin rule and the draw pile come built in. When the stories run out, lay the same cards in a grid and play a classic memory game. Matchy Matchy Memory keeps your real photos, which suits old family pictures.

  • What it is: Matchy Matchy turns your own photos into a memory card game.
  • The two games: Matchy Matchy Memory keeps your real photos, from $19.99. Matchy Matchy Magic re-draws them in 3D Film, Watercolor or Anime, from $29.99.
  • Sizes: Choose 12, 24 or 48 cards.
  • Before you pay: With Matchy Matchy Magic, you see your first card.
  • How you order: You upload from your phone at matchygame.com.
  • Shipping: Shipping is $5, and free when you order 2 or more decks. US only, ships in 3 to 5 business days.

The game suits a seated table of people who share some history. A crowd of strangers at a standing party will have less to add, so save the deck for the smaller gathering.

Ready to deal your own stories?

An older man and a young woman studying a grid of photo cards together at a cafe table

Pick the photos your table will have stories about. Choose real or re-drawn. Choose 12, 24 or 48 cards.

Start with Matchy Matchy Memory to keep the old photos just as they are, or try Matchy Matchy Magic to see your friends re-drawn in 3D Film, Watercolor or Anime. Order early if you want it on the holiday table. Questions? Write to us at hello@matchygame.com.